Greetings from The Booth!
I’m pretty sure I’m through with college sports…at least until football season. I’m very sure that I’m done with the NCAA.
To the disbelief of many experts and analysts around the sports world yesterday, the West Virginia University men’s basketball team was left out of the NCAA Basketball Tournament on Selection Sunday. Like many WVU fans, I was expecting my team to have its name called, but as each region’s bracket was announced, reality set in. WVU was on the outside looking in, the first team out of the tournament. Despite many “bracketologists,” including Joe Lunardi, deeming the Mountaineers safely in the 68-team field in the hours leading up to Selection Sunday. The NCAA Selection Committee felt differently.
However, the committee did feel like North Carolina and 15-loss Texas were deserving of a spot, and also invited 14, count ’em, 14 teams from the SEC to the party, a new record for a conference. UNC seems to be the team that displaced West Virginia, so let’s consider the following:
The 19-13 Mountaineers had 6 Quad 1 wins (wins against tournament-quality teams), while the 22-13 Tar Heels had a Quad 1 record of 1-12. WVU had quality wins, albeit early in the season against Gonzaga, Arizona, and Kansas (at Kansas). The Mountaineers also had a very bad loss to 16-seed Colorado in the opening round of the Big 12 Tournament, and probably would have been a lock had they won that game. WVU was also 10-10 in the Big 12, one of the toughest basketball conferences in the country. Admittedly, West Virginia did not play well in the second half of the season, but if the committee considers the entire body of work, as they say they do, there’s no question that the Mountaineers are deserving of a place in the big dance. Carolina is clearly in the tournament field on blue blood reputation.
It’s not a good look for the selection committee that its chairman is Bubba Cunningham, who is the AD at…wait for it…North Carolina. With a name like Bubba, surely there couldn’t be any backroom backslapping, right? Cunningham supposedly left the room during any discussion about his Tar Heels, but I’m not buying into the purity of that. Committee members know who their chairman is. I might also point out that Cunningham has a bonus system that increases the further Carolina advances in the tournament. Also not a good look.
Bubba’s reason (excuse) for WVU being left out? The Mountaineers would be without the injured Tucker DeVries in the tournament. DeVries, the son of West Virginia Head Coach Darian DeVries, hasn’t played since December, and suited up for a grand total of 8 games for West Virginia. Tucker DeVries hasn’t played for most of the season, so this reasoning makes absolutely no sense. Obviously, Cunningham didn’t do his homework, or had to pull something out of his backside to explain himself.
And, let’s not forget that WVU sued the NCAA in the 2023-24 season to get ineligible player RaeQuan Battle reinstated. The Mountaineers won that case and Battle returned to the court in the second half of the season. Would the NCAA hold a grudge against West Virginia because of that lawsuit? Just asking for a friend.
I wrote recently that doing the eye test would show that WVU is not tournament-worthy. But to be left out this way reeks of something like the infamous WWE “Montreal Screwjob.” However, there is little that can be done. West Virginia Governor Patrick Morrisey held a presser today (Monday) and hinted at litigation, but I’m not sure anything will come of this. It will be difficult to prove that there was a conspiracy to leave the Mountaineers out of the NCAA Tournament . I still like the move, as it continues to keep the kitchen light on as the roaches scurry.
In the meantime, dominos have started to fall at WVU. The Mountaineers have declined invitations from the NIT, and a new 16-team postseason tournament called The Crown. Freshman 3-point ace Jonathan Powell has entered the transfer portal, and rumors that Coach DeVries is leaving for Iowa continue to grow.
It is not a great day to be a Mountaineer.
RW
